News

Jun 03, 2024

How I lost the battle with my wind turbine

Duncan Veal shares a cautionary tale after losing a battle with his boat's wind generator… Wind generators provide an additional power source for keeping batteries topped-up, but they have the

Duncan Veal shares a cautionary tale after losing a battle with his boat's wind generator…

Wind generators provide an additional power source for keeping batteries topped-up, but they have the downside that the noise generated is annoying to all around.

I recently discovered a darker-side to wind generators that clipped my wings and meant I’m unable to sail for around 12 weeks.

Christine and I sail on Good as Gold, a Montevideo 43, a Solent-rigged ‘slutter’ designed and built in South Africa in 1989. The previous owners ensured Good as Gold is suitable for extended offshore trips having sailed her from Canada to Australia.

To run the lights, autohelm and sailing instruments, along with creature comforts (fridge, freezer, TV, stereo, water maker) she is equipped with four boat solar panels.

We upgraded these to provide up to 1.2KW, which usually meets our requirements without the need to run the motor for charging (we don’t have a genset).

Article continues below…

I confess, I’m frequently guilty of surrendering to the old adage, ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!’ But I…

Perhaps I should have known better. My sailing companion for the trip from Chichester Marina to Gosport, in my 19ft…

On cloudy days, or when the panels are shaded by the sail for extended periods, such as going north in winter, the solar may be insufficient for our needs so is supplemented by wind generation.

The boat was equipped with a simple (old-school) generator that provides around 2-4A at 10 knots of wind, increasing to 9A at 15 knots and 18A at 20 knots. Above 20 knots, thermostats in the motor cut the power production. Under ideal conditions the wind generator supplements our power generation by around 10%.

On the fateful day, we departed Hook Passage in the Whitsundays, Australia, in forecast 15-knot southerlies on an 11-mile passage south to Long Island. Normally it’s just Christine and I, however on this occasion we were joined by experienced crew Terry and Louise.

We don’t sail to wind often and thought it would be fun to test the boat and our ‘to-wind skills’ on a short passage. Winds were stronger than forecast, 20-25 knots, so we opted for a conservative sail plan of the Solent stay sail and one reef in the main.

The winds built to 30-plus knots providing the opportunity to test the second reef in the main and the seas became lively due to the strong current. It was a fun sail and we relaxed when we dropped the sails in preparation for anchoring in Happy Bay on Long Island.

Good as Gold, a Montevideo 43, Solent-rigged ‘slutter’

I’d forgotten to switch off the wind generator before departure and it was going crazy in the conditions. When turned off it didn’t stop due to the strong winds, instead it produced some dreadful noises and vibration.

The manual describes an alternative way of stopping the unit, which involves pulling a cord attached to the tail fin to rotate the generator out of the wind. The manual is clear that this should only be done using a boat hook, not your hand.

I clipped-on and stepped-up on the davit frame to reach the cord on the back fin (with my hand) to turn the generator out of the wind. Due to the conditions, the generator was extremely hard to turn around and, somehow, in tugging and on a lively sea, my arm slipped into the generator.

The wind generator after encountering Duncan’s arm

This resulted in some rather disturbing noises as the blades cut into flesh, shattering a bone and breaking off one of the fibreglass blades in the process. As this was a tad painful, I fell to the deck in distress – fortunately still clipped-on.

Crew (and skipper) have marine first aid training and went into ‘first aid’ mode. I was relieved of command, a good thing as I was contemplating continuing the adventure so as not to disappoint.

Frustrations of trying to eat a Coral Trout Burger with a cast after the battle with the wind turbine blades

After securing me in the cockpit, wounds were dressed, my condition was assessed and deemed to be OK for the two-hour journey the nearest port.

A distress call was made to Coral Seas Marina, we said that we were OK to make our own way to port and didn’t require a medical evacuation.

Coral Seas Marina organised a 70m superyacht berth, crew to catch lines, the ambulance and paramedics ready to whisk me to Proserpine Hospital.

The open break was deemed beyond the scope of Proserpine and I was transferred to McKay Base Hospital where I underwent surgery the following day to clean up the wounds and insert a plate.

All went well and after two days I was discharged to recuperate on the boat.

The length of recuperation is unclear at this point but it seems clear I won’t be able to use my right arm for much for a while. We are currently slow-sailing from Coral Seas Marina back to Sydney.

The previous owners advised us the wind generator had once dispatched a Booby. In my recovery time I calculated that the tip speed of the wind generator (diameter 1.7m) would be in excess of 570km/h at 20 knots.

The wind was 30-plus knots at the time of the accident! I have now decided there is no place on our boat for this noisy and murderous device!

*Send us boating experience story to [email protected] and if it’s published you’ll receive the original Jake Kavanagh cartoon at the top of the article.

This feature appeared in the February 2023 edition of Practical Boat Owner. For more articles like this, including DIY, money-saving advice, great boat projects, expert tips and ways to improve your boat’s performance, take out a magazine subscription to Britain’s best-selling boating magazine.

Subscribe, or make a gift for someone else, and you’ll always save at least 30% compared to newsstand prices.

See the latest PBO subscription deals on magazinesdirect.com